In the example below, students
are directed to respond to the reading by considering specific questions, but
they are also directed to structure their answers as a coherent piece of writing
rather than a series of answers. If used as an initial assignment, such writing
can give you a quick sense of the range of abilities and provide you with
immediate student writing to use as you prepare the first major written
assignment.
Reading Response for NEA, “Trends in
Literature Participation, 1982 – 2002” from Reading at Risk
In “Trends in
Literature Participation, 1982 – 2002,” the National Endowment for the Arts
presents a picture of trends in literary reading over the past couple of
decades. The report refers both to overall numbers of literary readers and
to rates of literary reading. It also breaks these figures down
demographically: by gender, race, level of education, and age.
Write a response that
analyzes the NEA report. As you respond, focus on three things:
First, look at the
overall figures in the first few sections both for numbers of readers
and for the rates of literary reading and other literary participation.
What do these different kinds of numbers mean, and what kinds of changes
in overall literary reading and participation do they suggest have
occurred? What numbers do you find most revealing, interesting,
questionable, or confusing?
Second, follow the
data for one particular demographic group. What kinds of changes have
occurred for this group? How do they compare to the changes in other
groups? Does the report indicate reasons for these differences? What
sorts of explanations might you offer?
Third, look at the
causes the NEA suggests are behind the overall changes in reading
patterns. Do you find their suggestions reasonable? What other factors
do you think might account for the changes the report documents?
You need not follow
any particular format in composing your response, but be sure to develop a
logical organization. Although the questions should guide your analysis of
the report, you should not simply answer each question and move on. Instead,
compose a coherent, disciplined, brief essay that responds to the report.
Use the questions above to get started and focus your attention. Please feel
free to add any kinds of analysis or response you believe are important but
not covered in these questions.