Teaching Reading -- Methods, Claims and Evidence

Home
Up
FAQs
Planning the Course
Teaching Inquiry
Teaching Writing
Additional Resources

Reading as a Researcher
Activity 3: reading methods, claims and evidence (illustrated with Len-Ríos et. al)

Focusing discussion of the readings on evidence, claims and methodology is a useful way of helping students see the readings as examples for their own projects and presentations of research. We use discussion questions like those we provide below in a number of ways:

  •     as prompts for whole class discussion

  •     as homework questions either on-line or in writing

  •     as structured group work

Here we provide some questions for the Len-Ríos et. al reading.

Reading Questions for Len-Ríos et. al, "Representations of Women in News and Photos: Comparing Content to Perceptions"

word version download

Reading Questions for Len-Rios et al., “Representations of Women in News and Photos: Comparing Content to Perceptions”

  1. Consider the differences between the “content analysis” that Len-Rios et al. complete and their “perception studies.”
    1. Why bother breaking the research project down in this way? What does it add to their research project to include both?
    2. What different methods do they develop for measuring content and for measuring perceptions? Are these appropriate? 
    3. What kinds of conclusions do they draw for each area? How does pooling these conclusions help them in the final discussion section?

     

  1. The authors of this article make some powerful, controversial and broad claims in the first few paragraphs. How do they:
    1. Show that these claims are not uninformed opinions, but are part of a broader conversation (be specific)?
    2. Link these claims to their specific research project: in the beginning, through the body of the essay, and in the conclusion?

See other resources for Teaching Reading Back Next

Home ] Up ]

Send mail to mmarshall@miami.edu with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2008 Composing Inquiry: Methods and Readings for Investigation and Writing
Last modified: 02/21/08. Contributors to this site include: Margaret Marshall, Andrew Strycharski, April Mann, Isis Artze-Vega, Patty Malloy, John Wafer.